The topic of whether it is acceptable for a Christian to use or own a dreamcatcher is one that does not have a definitive “right or wrong” answer according to the Bible. There are arguments on both sides of the issue that can be made from a biblical perspective. Ultimately, it comes down to one’s personal convictions and their conscience before God. Here is an overview of some of the key considerations around this issue:
What is a dreamcatcher?
A dreamcatcher is a handmade object originating from Native American culture that is usually made out of a small round or teardrop-shaped frame wrapped in a net or web of natural fibers such as sinew or plant fibers. Feathers and beads are usually attached to the bottom of the frame. The purpose of a dreamcatcher is to “catch” bad dreams or negative thoughts in its web, allowing only good dreams to filter through the center hole and float down the feathers to the sleeping person below. They are commonly hung over a bed or place where one sleeps.
Concerns from a Christian perspective
One of the main concerns some Christians raise about dreamcatchers is that they originate from Native American spiritual and cultural traditions, not Christianity. Specific tribes have various legends and spiritual meanings attached to the dreamcatcher related to filtering good and bad dreams. Some view dreamcatchers as having mystical energy or properties rooted in non-Christian spiritual beliefs. This causes concerns about possible conflicts with biblical teaching and warnings about involvement in non-Christian spiritual practices.
Additionally, some Christians feel dreamcatchers may cross into “idol” territory if too much meaning or power is ascribed to them as physical objects. They warn against looking to objects like dreamcatchers for spiritual protection rather than turning to God alone.
Arguments for acceptable use by Christians
Those who believe it is acceptable for Christians to use dreamcatchers make the case that for many people today, they are primarily considered decorative objects or cultural artifacts, not religious icons. Just like yoga poses or origami, some argue that dreamcatchers have been sufficiently disconnected from any original non-Christian spiritual meaning to be neutral cultural symbols.
Additionally, some note that objects have no inherent power in and of themselves – spiritual or otherwise. Things like dreamcatchers only have whatever meaning the owner assigns to them. As long as someone does not view a dreamcatcher as a source of mystical power or spiritual protection, but merely as a decorative gift or artifact, then ownership does not conflict with biblical principles.
Questions to consider
Here are some questions for Christians to consider when deciding whether or not dreamcatchers are acceptable for them to use or display:
- Do I understand and feel comfortable with the origins and original meaning behind dreamcatchers?
- Will owning or using a dreamcatcher violate my personal convictions before God?
- Could my use of a dreamcatcher encourage others to dabble in non-Christian spiritual practices it may be associated with?
- Am I ascribing any spiritual power or mystical energy to the dreamcatcher itself rather than recognizing God as my sole source of protection?
- Might my use of a dreamcatcher communicate endorsement of unbiblical beliefs to other Christians who are sensitive to perceived involvement in non-Christian practices?
Managing differences of opinion among Christians
Given the lack of definitive biblical prohibition, whether or not Christians should use dreamcatchers is often a matter of personal conviction and Christian freedom. Romans 14 provides guidance on handling differences on issues like this with grace, respecting the perspectives of other believers.
Those comfortable using dreamcatchers should be careful not to flaunt them in a way that causes others with stricter standards to stumble. Conversely, those avoiding dreamcatchers should be cautious about judging the spirituality of fellow Christians who do not share the same view.
Philippians 2:3-4 offers wise counsel: “Do nothing from selfish ambition or conceit, but in humility count others more significant than yourselves. Let each of you look not only to his own interests, but also to the interests of others.” Seeking to serve others above selfish interests glorifies Christ.
Principles for Christian discernment
When evaluating practices like dreamcatcher use, these biblical principles can help provide guidance:
- Be transformed by the renewing of your mind (Romans 12:2) – evaluate cultural elements through the lens of Scripture.
- Avoid that which promotes lust of the flesh, lust of the eyes, pride of life (1 John 2:15-17) – beware spiritual snares.
- Abstain from sinful practices, flee idolatry (1 Corinthians 10:14; 1 Thessalonians 5:22) – maintain pure worship.
- Walk in love, act in faith (1 Corinthians 13; 2 Corinthians 5:7) – let Christlike character guide your choices.
- Pursue righteousness, peace, edification of others (Romans 14:19; Hebrews 12:14) – make choices that build up community.
- Glorify Christ in all you do (1 Corinthians 10:31; Colossians 3:17) – keep God’s honor foremost.
Conclusions
There is room for reasonable debate among Christians regarding whether or not using dreamcatchers is acceptable. Each believer must follow their own conscience as they evaluate cultural practices in light of Scripture and sensitivities of other Christians.
While dreamcatcher use does not seem to be explicitly prohibited in Scripture, it is wise to enter into the discernment process carefully and humbly. The highest principles should be glorifying Christ, edifying others, acting in love, and avoiding potential spiritual snares.
Christians wanting to display dreamcatchers should consider both their personal convictions and also how their choices may be perceived. They should be willing to lovingly discuss their views with other believers who hold differing standards. Through openness, gentleness and communication, Christians can navigate issues like these with maturity and grace.